timetogame.org

Magic Quiter · Joined: 02 Oct 2007 Posts: 21

Now that 10th edition isn't exactly new, what are people's thoughts on it. Is it good, does it suck, or is it the best edition since Revised? (Duals, lots of them) Plus, if there are people reading these posts in the forum but aren't replying, please say something so we know you are out there. It looks deserted here. "All by myseeeelfff, don't want to be all by myseeeeelffff!"

PyroPhantom · Posted: Wed Oct 10, 2007 2:42 pm Post subject:

10th edition perks:

Shivan Dragon
Birds of Paradise
Pain Lands (not a bayou or badlands or taiga, but I'll live...unless I'm at one and need to tap it for a color, then I'm in trouble. Or Taliban...Take it for the team! Get'n my virgins!)
Drafting it is fun, except for the time when we did two 10th and a time spiral. That was just awful.
Wrath of God!
All cards are black border. Cool.

10th edition non-perks:
Wizards of the coast are still allowing them to print some version of counterspells. Argh.
I'd still like to see Force of Nature, Jokulhaups, Nevineral's disk, Apocolypse, more slivers (after all, there was just a whole block with slivers). And maybe some better mana excellorators. I'm not asking for a Black Lotus (though that would be nice). I'd like to see things like lotus petals and mox diamonds.

Overall...GO LORWYN!!!
_________________
I have opinions of my own -- strong opinions -- but I don't always agree with them. - George Bush

spiderchick · Joined: 19 Aug 2007 Posts: 16

YAY counterspells. Wish they hadn't done away with a few of them (i.e. Mana Leak) and reprinted others (i.e. Cancel).

Kind of upset that I got rid of my 9th ed. pain lands, but I'll live since they are easier to find and get now. Any need Ravnica lands?

Magic Quiter · Joined: 02 Oct 2007 Posts: 21

10th edition should have left in Mana Leak (one of my favorite counterspells) but atleast they gave us some kind of two mana counterspell in the form of Spiketail Hatchling. Blue Skies Forever!!!